Blog – ExamWorks Compliance Solutions

CMS Releases 2026 WCMSA Benchmark Data

Written by Michael Flower | Nov 17, 2026, 2:58:27 PM

Earlier this week the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) released the WCMSA Fiscal Year Statistics 2022-2026, which examines trends in Workers' Compensation Medicare Set-Aside (WCMSA) submissions over the past five years. CMS has released this data for the last several years, providing a snapshot of the CMS submission process, complete with trends on volumes, counter-highers, and MSA and settlement amount averages. This year’s report provides a number of interesting data points that may, to the untrained eye, be somewhat counter-intuitive.

Of note:
•    There was an increase in CMS approved WCMSAs by about 11% (13,884 to 15,596)
•    Average proposed settlement amount decreased by 7% (~$11,000)
•    Average proposed WCMSA amount continued a five year streak of decreasing slightly to $68,160.15
•    The average WCMSA recommended amount decreased by ~$3,500 (from $86,168.57 to $82,681.25)

Unpacking the Data

Increase in WCMSA Submissions

The first number that jumps off the page is that more parties are submitting WCMSAs to CMS for approval as submissions jumped from 13,884 to 15,596.  While there has been some fluctuation in submissions over the past five years, it is notable that this leap is within the first full year of the mandatory WCMSA data reporting and in a year when CMS eliminated the review of zero allocations – removing a significant number of cases eligible for review. CMS now has a new level of visibility into what parties do or do not do to account for Medicare’s interest with regard to future medical allocations.  It is possible this increase of CMS approvals is linked to the new reporting requirement, although limited data makes this impossible to definitively know.
Some industry observers speculated that the number of submitted MSAs would drop or even collapse as CMS demanded to know the WCMSA amount in all workers’ comp settlements involving a Medicare beneficiary. In year one, at least, that speculation has not only proven to be unfounded but in fact flat out wrong. While it is too early to identify whether this trend is more of a blip or suggests a the start of a longer-term trend, it’s possible that some workers’ comp claims payers became more cautious about settling outside of CMS’ prying eyes. 

Although submission is never required the agency’s policy is that they can deny related claims up to the full value of the settlement, where CMS review and approval is not obtained. Regardless of the path chosen, ECS’ advice to all settling parties is to act reasonably at the time of the settlement and if CMS review is ignored, obtain a legitimate report from a qualified MSP compliance expert that clearly outlines expected future medical costs.

Total WCRC recommended WCMSA amount ticking down

While there has been some fluctuation over the last five years, the total WCRC recommended WCMSA amount has remained seemingly inflation-proof, even decreasing close to 2022 levels.  Specifically, the recommended medication amount has continued to see marked decreases every year for the last five year, nearly 22% over a five year period.  On top of that, average CMS approved medical amount has remained consistent with almost no notable change over the last four years.  

Approved vs Proposed WCMSA

Another statistic that also hasn’t changed much is the variance in the proposed amount against what CMS ends up recommending for the WCMSA, which is at 21% this past year.  The raw, and limited, data doesn’t explain why proposals continue to run low.  This snapshot contains no concrete explanation, but could include submissions being more aggressive in proposing a lower allocation amount and CMS continuing to remain very conservative.

Conclusions

Again, this limited snapshot prevents the ability to make any sweeping conclusions about why there has been movement in the numbers.  However, the consistency in CMS recommended total WCMSA amounts over the past five years in the face of otherwise increased healthcare costs is impressive.  The data also underscores the value in having an experienced allocation company, such as ECS, in your corner to navigate what is the lowest defensible allocation amount for CMS consideration. ECS specializes in not only allocating the lowest defensible allocation amount, but ECS also provides mitigation recommendations and services to put you in the best position for CMS agreeing to a lower future medical allocation.  And, if you elect not to submit or can’t submit, indemnification is available on every ECS allocation.

ExamWorks Compliance Solutions continuously monitors regulatory and legislative developments in the Medicare Secondary Payer space. For further information about this Report or if you have any questions, contact Michael Flower at Michael.flower@examworkscompliance.com.